With countless test-preparation options available, from large national companies to independent online tutors, parents often struggle to distinguish effective programs from marketing hype. Michael Romano, founder of Mr. Test Prep, argues that the key lies in asking the right questions before committing. Drawing on nearly three decades of experience and having coached over 4,000 students since 1997, Romano offers a practical framework for evaluating SAT and ACT tutors.
The first question parents should ask is who will actually teach their student. Many companies sell a program but assign a different, less experienced tutor later. Romano personally coaches every student, bringing his extensive track record to each session. Because sessions are online, students nationwide can work directly with him.
Second, does a diagnostic come before the preparation plan? A meaningful diagnostic goes beyond scores to reveal how a student approaches the test—accuracy, pacing, question patterns, and decision-making. Mr. Test Prep begins with a free two-hour trial session focused on diagnostic work, not a predetermined curriculum.
Third, how will the tutor decide between the SAT and ACT? Romano cautions against simply choosing the test with the higher initial score. Instead, the decision should hinge on which weaknesses are most responsive to instruction. Watching the student work under timed conditions provides the necessary insight.
Fourth, what are the financial commitments and guarantee terms? Families should scrutinize score guarantees for hidden conditions, such as required homework. Mr. Test Prep uses a pay-as-you-go model with a session cap based on the student's starting point and goals. If the target score is reached early, families stop paying. If the cap is reached without achieving the goal, additional coaching continues at no extra charge—and without mandatory homework.
Fifth, what happens between sessions? Romano maintains a no-homework philosophy. While independent practice is allowed, no test-prep homework is required. Instead, preparation is concentrated in sessions where Romano can observe and adjust the student's approach in real time.
Sixth, how do you prepare students for performance under pressure? Knowing the material is only part of test-day success. Mr. Test Prep combines the Mr. Test Prep Method™ for tactical execution with A-Game Access™ to address the student's mental state, helping them access what they know when it matters most.
Finally, can my student try the program before we commit? Mr. Test Prep offers a free two-hour trial session nationwide. The student works through diagnostic material while Romano observes and offers feedback. A follow-up Zoom meeting with the student and parent reviews findings, discusses test choice, sets target scores, and outlines a plan. A written proposal follows by email.
These questions empower families to look beyond sales pitches and ensure their investment truly supports their child's success. As Romano notes, "Parents shouldn't have to make a large commitment just to find out whether the relationship works. Let the student experience the process first. Then everyone can make a much more informed decision."
